
I just got finished watching an episode of an NBC show called Parks & Recreation. It's the show in which Amy Poehler plays a character very much like the one Steve Carell plays in The Office.
I want to go on record as saying that this is not about the quality of the script, nor about Poehler, who is generally funny in most roles that she plays. But I have to say: enough.
It's time to put away the Mockumentary genre where the humor is based entirely on how stupid someone is, or rude, or generally self-humiliating.
I was a huge fan of the British version of The Office. Ricky Gervais was absolutely brilliant, as was the script, and we'd never really seen anything like it before. Likewise, I liked the U.S. version of The Office with Carell, who brought some interesting dimension to that baffoon boss character. That show also was carried by the fantastic Jenna Fisher and John Krasinski, who were so pleasant to watch, especially for the first couple years of the show.
But watching P&R really highlighted for me the weakness of this genre, and why I hope it will go away soon. What is it about this time in history that compels us to laugh at the misfortunes of others? What is it about cringing that seems so central to humor in 2009?
I don't have the answer; I just want to stop cringing. Give me a laugh track again. Or at least shows that don't make me want to die when I watch them. Die is a little strong. But Chuck put it pretty well tonight. He said: "When did someone's bad day at work become entertainment?"
A good question.
I wish Poehler success with any vehicle she has, although this one really has me torn. Maybe I'll say I wish her success, but I'll be sitting this one out.
Add a comment