
I remember staying up late to watch the MTV Video Music Awards. The year was 1984, I was 13 and had severe acne and a nose that my face would need five more years - minimum - to grow into.
And there was Modonna, in a wedding dress, writhing around on stage while singing "Like A Virgin."
I remember how my stepfather and mother reacted. Shock, some amusement (my stepfather), chagrin about me seeing this overt sexual behavior.
For my part, I was captivated. I knew what she was doing was naughty, and I knew I wasn't supposed to be seeing her simulate orgasm in a wedding dress. I couldn't look away. I knew we'd all be talking about it tomorrow, at school.
Here are the things that didn't happen to me because I witnessed this inappropriate television behavior: I didn't become a prostitute. I didn't decide that this was how all brides behaved, or should behave. I didn't rush out to find a girl to do this for me, nor did I mimic the behavior myself in any future high school stage performances.
You see, Madonna wasn't my role model. I know, I know, I was a guy, not a girl. But I was a gay guy. Even then, I knew I was gay. And I didn't think for a moment that I'd seen something I should emulate. Instead, I saw something that I would digest in time -- some immediately, some over the next week while hearing people yap about what a slut Madonna was, and some decades later, when Adam Lambert simulated oral sex and then deep kissed a band member during a performance of his single "For Your Entertainment" at the American Music Awards.
I say this because I am reading a lot about people who are outraged, and many of these people are saying that it's not a matter of gay or straight, it's a matter of appropriate or inappropriate.
Look. I understand. If I had a 12 year old, I wouldn't want him or her to see such behavior either. It's an inborn instinct, to protect our children from confusion and other uncomfortable emotions.
But let's be real. Madonna caused shock when she writhed, Elvis caused shock when he gyrated, but neither caused the hubub that Adam caused. Of course his sexuality is the issue. Otherwise, the "kiss" wouldn't be part of the conversation. C'mon. Could you imagine if this was Prince, and Prince had made out with a female keyboardist on stage? You really think Good Morning America would have canceled Prince's performance the next day? No, because this is 2009, not 1959. The oral sex simulation might have gotten some people talking, but I don't think he'd be canceled.
Adam was canceled because he pushed the envelope and he's a gay male. This is the last taboo. We are okay with Britney and Madonna kissing, we're okay with songs for females that say "I kissed a girl and I liked it." If a male artist sang a song called "I kissed a boy and I liked it," it would not be a top 10 hit. I promise.
I just think we should face reality when having discussions about such things. I do not know why people feel the strong urge to deny homophobia when it rears it's ugly head, but they do. That's why so much of the criticism begins with "I'm not homophobic, but..."
Now I just need to say that truthfully, I have mixed feelings about what happened up on that stage last weekend. I love Adam, but when I saw the clip, I thought he didn't sing the song very well at all, and I thought the performance was over the top for sure. But that said, I do not think such performances are particularly dangerous for our youth.
Kids are smart. Are they impacted by what they see on TV? Sure. But they also understand context. When I was 13 and watching Madonna in her wedding dress, I knew this was "pushing the envelope" behavior meant to cause controversy and sell records. As precocious as I was, it did nothing to make me more precocious.
My point is this: invariably some gay boys may emulate this behavior. But they would have anyway. Kids have personalities. Some are prone to overt sexual behavior, and some are prone to sitting alone in their rooms and reading books. I thought my mother was off base 25 years ago when she worried about me seeing Madonna, and I think so today, when I hear people scream about how Adam's performance corrupted young eyes.
When it comes to overt gay sexuality, young eyes get it. It's the older eyes I'm most worried about.
By the way: The CD "For Your Entertainment" is fantastic. A review is upcoming.
